Wheelchair provision redesign project
- Case studies
Charlotte and Kimberley presented how they have worked together to to deliver a sustainable, patient-centered wheelchair service.
Firstly, I'm Charlotte Wilson. I'm the operations manager for Stroke.Previously, I managed a wheelchair service in specialist.
So I'm just going to do a bit of a whistle-stop tour around some of the wheelchair project work that we completed over the last couple of years. Next slide, please.
Thank you. So a bit of the background, really.
So, we've had this service for around 20 years, and predominantly it's always been a bit of a more complex service, mainly because it sits quite differently to the rest of our organization with the KPIs.
So many services need to meet a 18-week RTT, but it tends to be on first assessment, and then whatever happens after that happens. With the wheelchair-
Is that a question there? Sorry. No?
Okay. So, with the wheelchairs KPI, we have to hand equipment over within 18 weeks. So that's quite tricky to meet when you're relying on a number of different areas, such as suppliers, and assessments, and yeah, handover, building equipment, whatnot. But the main issue for us, and for this project, was we picked up the West in 2018, and quite quickly our patients were more complex, there was a number of unmet needs.
So the vision that we thought that we were gaining when we picked up that additional service actually was significantly higher, which you can see by the numbers on the screen. Next slide, please.
So, what was the problem that we were trying to solve here?
Well, it's to deliver a sustainable, patient-centered wheelchair service, and there's a number of areas that we try to sort of prioritize in a way of really exploring what the impossible was and looking at marginal gains.
And rather than us just focusing on the patients, the KPIs, and the never-ending growing caseload, we try to look at the service as a whole and try to break it down into more measurable chunks. Next slide, please.
Yep. So to deliver this project, we looked at a number of areas that we wanted to focus on. And we drafted a PID, a document that creates our sort of essentials, the deliverables that we wanted to really understand what the aim that we wanted to come out of this project.
We then developed a number of options for our board, who then determined where our focus was going to be on. And a number of those areas that we looked at was the capacity versus demand, the staff engagement, and the risk matrix, around us really looking at that.
Next steps. Next slide. Kimberley, you can jump in at any point.
Okay.
Okay. So leading through change and influence, I think the biggest areas here was to focus on the building of the shared vision, so we really invested a lot in our MDTs. We used data and project management tools to provide a clear evidence for change and supporting some of our decision-making.
We managed resistance to change through regular communications.
We had listening events, and we maintained the momentum of celebrating quick wins, to keep the staff engaged and wanting to keep that drive of moving forward. And on the screen you can see some of the tools that we used to keep leading through change. Next slide, please.
So the relationships and the collaborative leadership, why is this important?
I think some of the areas that I felt was really important was to build these relationships with the key stakeholders that we have to work with in every single day, that we almost kind of forget about, or we take it for granted, but these relationships mean that we can improve patients' outcomes through coordinated care. We can build better decision-making by combining clinical expertise with operational oversight.
We have strong quality and safety and governance oversight to help us keep moving our vision forward. We have shared goals with all of our key stakeholders. We also sort of focus a little bit more on our leadership styles and our adaptive leadership throughout the process of change.
We worked, like I said, collaboratively with our stakeholders, and I think I couldn't emphasize more building that strong relationships around us, really moving this project forward.
I think I would add to that, Charlotte, that... Sorry everyone.
For those of you who don't know me, I'm Kimberley Jordan, and I'm Improvement and Transformation Practitioner with our improvement team. But prior to that, I was a project manager with NCHC, and I managed this project with Charlotte. So I think I'll just add to this, just a little bit of background.
Charlotte came into this service, and it was, for want of a better way of describing it, there was a difficult culture, which had been ingrained within the service for many years. There'd been quite a few projects that had been started with this service, and had actually failed or not come to anything, to the point that it actually became a really, really difficult project to give a title to because there'd been so many transformations and redesigns and so on and so forth.
And, I think what Charlotte did when she came into this service was really, really work with all of those relationships.
And to get all of that service, the entire service on board was just an absolute feat, quite frankly. Sorry, Charlotte, back to you.
No, great, thanks.
Yeah, next slide, please.
And then we've got a little bit of the middle management.
So, I think everyone can relate to this.
We're sort of trying our best to manage the visions with the demands from the leadership team above us. You've also got the staff below us, but you've also got the system that we work within and trying to manage those conflicting priorities, but always having a line of sight to a patient, it can be really tricky and quite overwhelming. And I think that's where that support from the project team and making sure that our vision and values are aligned, I think is crucial for us to continue to drive that change. Next slide, please.
Okay, so the deliverables. So again, there's a number of deliverables throughout this project, and we couldn't list them all because it was actually a really big project. But again, focusing on marginal gains, exploring the key aspects of the pathway and really breaking those bits down, and cherry-picking all the areas that we think we can influence and make change, that will have positive outcomes for patients. And there's a number of really positive things that we've done there.
And I suppose the top one is just looking at the equipment range.
We have such a large range that we have patients picking from Ferraris in a wheelchair to a really basic model.
And it's really looking at, is that fair?
Can we offer that consistently across the NHS? No, we couldn't.
So we had to realign a number of those, to reflect other wheelchair services as well. Next slide, please.
Yep, that's just the same thing. We can skip over that one.
Yeah, and so this I think is a really interesting one.
So this is the caseload trajectory, and I love a visual tool, so this is great for me. So, this tells us that, as you can see, the caseload has gone from the beginning when we first picked up that service of 808 patients all the way up to over 1,200 patients. And that, for us, throughout the first two years of this project, was more trying to work with the team and understand that change needs to come and where their buy-in was. There was already historical established projects that just weren't working.
So what you can see at the moment is the first red dot, you can see where it's just above the 808. The current staffing model there was actually 9.29 whole time equivalents.
So that was the benchmarking that we started with, and there was two vacancies, so we hadn't completely recruited all of those posts.
We then was trying to work through a couple of projects that weren't really working. Then you'll come to the first blue dot, which is the blues represent, a data cleansing where we've gone through our caseload.
We had a number of patients that either duplicated or their equipment's been handed over, or they didn't need the service anymore and just hadn't been discharged.
The green dot represents when Kimberley and I started a new project and said, "We're not going to change it from this point.This is where we're going," and we sort of was really firm, and we're going to see this through to the end.
And then you move over to the little amber dot, which is when we implemented direct issue. So this is equipment that can be prescribed to a patient without seeing a clinician, and we've done a lot of work to create a tool where admin can prescribe this equipment really straightforward without taking any of our clinical capacity.
Then the purple dot represents when we had two whole-time equivalent members of staff going on maternity leave, and for this service we've had a number of issues with recruitment and it's been that for us made us think, "Oh gosh, what are we going to do now?" So the next red dot, and I think this is a really pivotal part of where we've come to, which marginal gains has been such a benefit, is that last red dot, you've currently got two whole-time senior clinicians and two APs.
So the first red dot you had 9.29 whole-time equivalents, but you was holding two vacancies. The next red dot you've got four whole-time equivalents, and two of those are on registered clinicians and we still continue to recover the service.
So what that tells us is that it didn't matter how much money you threw at this service or how much staff you threw at the service, it was never going to work.
You was never going to recover the service like that. It needed marginal gains.
It needed to look at everything and really determine how you could manage this service. What we did do is offset some of the, um, non-pay to, um, the, um, the... Sorry, the PAYE to the non-pay to cover the deficit.
So we actually reduced our staffing structure throughout this project to cover the cost of the deficit, but we modeled a sustainable service.
So I think that was really crucial. I think the other thing to throw in there was that we actually completed a business case with the ICB, who acknowledged that the service was underfunded, but it was rejected because they just couldn't give us any more money.
So our final vision was to we modeled a sustainable service within the cost envelope. And this is where we sort of ended up. But actually as you can see, although we wasn't given any additional funding to cover the backlog, we still continue to recover the service with marginal gains.
And so it's just a touch base on that. Sorry. You can keep that one up though.
So what I've just, I've just got a note of what made a difference here.
So it's that marginal gains to creative thinking, staff engagement, patient engagement, that continuous review and learning.
So we constantly self-checked, where we were going, what was happening, every challenge or barrier that got thrown of us or a curve ball, we continuously adapt to this project to make sure that we could achieve it at the end of recovering a service. I think maintaining the momentum and asking the why, constantly asking why. Why does it need to be a clinician? Why does it have to be a senior clinician?
What is the risk, knowing that we had patients that wasn't given equipment in a timely manner that was causing harm to them?
So, thank you for the next slide. So did the vision change?
It absolutely changed more often than I would care to own up to I think.
It was a very challenging time, but we did overcome a number of barriers.
So, the recruitment of staffing was really challenging.
Relying on new qualified staff, the required competency and development, that was tricky. So bringing newly qualified staff into a service that was undergoing such a huge transformation was really difficult.
I think we had an impact on retention, staff resilience, and balancing the operational demand with quality. I think that was quite a tricky one.
We come up with a number of barriers.
We have limited IT capacity to support our project.
There was delays in obtaining approval around our referral form by the LMC.
So we had a number of challenges, but we did overcome majority of those and still was able to recover a service. Next slide please.
Does that look blurry to everybody?
Yeah. Oh, there we go.
So learning from barriers. So develop the resilience and adaptability and I think yeah, we had to be really resilient and I think that was something that needed to continue. Improving communication transparency, again, that's key.
I think communicating with our team, we had a number of meetings.
We often shared visual tools. We done a number of staff surveys, questionnaires, touchpoints, temperature checks. We constantly engaged.
We had open days with patients, like coffee and cake days.
We also worked really closely with our prosthetics team as we were in the same building. We've done a lot of joint work with them.
Again, who's part of our service but is a subcontractor run by an outsourced service.
And again, with all of our positive tools, I do love a leadership tool and I've listed a couple on there in case she's want to have a little look.
Next slide please. Kim, I'll let you go on this one.
Thank you, Charlotte. So I mean, what Charlotte's given you all is really comprehensive. Just to go back into some of those challenges that she's mentioned. So one of the main barriers we've had to overcome was the pushback from GPs regarding the changes we wish to make to the referral form.
Which was the referral form was going to be absolutely critical in being able to enable our admin team to triage and release some of the clinical capacity back to the clinicians. So the changes we were proposing at the time were really minimal, and we were actually stripping out a lot of the information that we were requesting from referrers.
But, unfortunately for us, we were attempting to amend the referral form at a time of industrial action. So GPs were pushing back on how much information they were being requested to provide on referral forms, and even though we were paring back the information, it just took months and months and months of persuasion and negotiation to reach an agreement.
And perseverance here was like absolutely key, and creating workarounds like creating a guide to enable admin to triage using the existing referral form in the interim period. There were some other things that, desirable deliverables, that had come through from senior leadership at the beginning of the project, such as having a fully electronic referral system and an automated patient communication system, which would work two ways.
Both of those had originally been on the PID as essential deliverables. We, as Charlotte said, didn't have the IT resource, which had been promised at the beginning of the project. So some of that wasn't able to be realized. But also if we had used certain tools at that time, what we would have found out was that a lot of it wouldn't have actually made that much of a difference to the service.
So tools, I'm not going to go into the nitty-gritty of the tools that you can see on the screen here because I don't want to teach you all how to suck eggs or anything. But, if we'd used like a fishbone diagram, five whys, an impact versus effort matrix in addition to some brainstorming activities, what we would've found was that by implementing a fully electronic referral system and an automated patient communication system, the benefits would not have outweighed the cost.
Quite late, I think a few months into the life cycle of the project, IT ran a rudimentary model and found that it was only going to save us two admin days a year, if we'd actually moved towards those electronic referrals.
So whilst they seemed like it would be all singing or dancing and senior leadership were really keen on that, it just wouldn't have made much of a difference.
So I suppose in a nutshell, what I'm saying is These tools, which at the time that I was managing this project, I wasn't really equipped with.
Knowing what I know now, I would definitely implement these into the information-gathering, the sort of deep-dive stage of a project and could end up saving quite a lot of time and resources spent on wasted meetings and so on and so forth.
Back to you, Charlotte.
Thank you. And yeah, I suppose everything that Kim said, there was a number of things that we probably would do differently.
And you learn, don't you? So that's great. We learn a lot, so that's really positive.
And I think the key successes is that strengthening the team engagement and morale.
So although we had so many challenges, the staff now are seeing the benefits of all of the changes that we suggested, and they've implemented it. They've been embedded. And obviously, I've handed that service over now to the new service lead, and she's continuing that work. So that's really positive.
I think improving service delivery outcomes, I can't stress enough. These people really need this wheelchair within an 18-week pathway, and although we've done this work to recover the service as much as possible, we still haven't factored in the fact that we aren't 18-week compliant, and that's something that will need to be taken forward. Supporting staff development and retention, again, using these wheelchair skills in the community.
So giving staff all of those tools and skills to be able to develop throughout the whole of our services. We love to grow our own, so we like to share that learning, so I think that's really positive.
And obviously enhancing operational efficiencies. Next slide, please.
Oh. Yeah, and I think this is the last slide.
So it's just about having a vision, sharing a vision, and influencing your team to deliver. I can't share that enough. I think constantly asking why.
Why does that happen? Being brave, inspiring your team.
I think my pet hate is when they say, "It's always been like this." That's a red flag. We need to challenge that a little bit more and find out the whys and the hows. I think we like to label services as specialist, and many of them are specialist services, but I think you do need to look outside the box, and this demonstrates bringing in two APs, who I would probably say are single-handedly holding that wheelchair service down right now is incredible.
And if you said that two years ago, I'd say, "Absolutely not. That's never going to happen." It just proves that marginal gains and that constantly nagging the why, what's the risk? It does move clinical services on.
Thank you.