RICE and projection portal
- Case studies
Alexander Keep, Design and Impact Engagement Lead in the Improvement and Transformation Team
The Improvement and Transformation Team have created a projection portal that will predict the impact a project may have. The portal can be used alongside the RICE framework.
Right. So I'm going to talk to you about RICE and a projection portal we made.
So I'm going to go quite quickly, but I can share stuff afterwards.
So this was all for the Children's Neurodiversity programme, also known as ND.
And if you know anything about the children's ND programme, it's a very messy beast with lots of issues across different areas, but most notably the rather large waiting list. So this is just us using the RICE tool and a little portal product that I made to just go through the ideas and comes out with the most promising ones at the end.
So what is the RICE framework? So it's just a prioritization tool like many others. You have your reach, impact, confidence, and effort.
So your reach is how many people it's going to affect over a certain amount of time. So it could be three months, six months, a year. You've got your impact.
So together as a group, you decide how much impact is this going to have, and you score it based on that. And then you've got your confidence rating.
So how confident are you thinking it's going to reach that level of impact?
And obviously, if you have something with a low confidence, that's quite a risky idea to take forward because you don't think it's actually going to get it.
And then you've got effort, which is basically how many people will it take to do it. And you can do it in hours. You can do it in weeks.
It doesn't really matter. I prefer person days and work things out that way.
But once you have all those numbers, you can use this little formula to give you a nice little score, and then you can list all your different ideas that you've got and put a score next to them so you can get an idea of which one's going to have more impact or get the goal that you want.
So how do we use this in reality? So we had a gigantic workshop for ND where we got a load of clinicians, we got some users. We got basically a whole bunch of people across the three geographies in a room and got them to come up with their wildest ideas that they can to tackle the waiting list. And this is what we came up with, the great walls of ND, and on those walls are these neuro notes.
So it started off with giving the idea a name, quick description, and then an expectation of what they think the impact would be.
So how do you go from that to then RICE scoring?
So we went down this little funnel here.
So you started off with the giant notes, and then we did a bit of AI assisting. We scanned them all to group and theme them and remove the duplicates.
And then we sent out a survey to the staff that were all part of the workshop to start ranking and voting which ones they think were the best ones.
And then from that, we started taking the most favored ones to start looking at scoring and doing some impact projections, which then led to league table scorings and then taking some initiatives forward.
So we went from 50 ideas to 35 to 10 to seven to three, and then we took those initiatives forward to pilot.
So this is the bit that I'm rushing towards, by the way.
So rather than just talk about it, I'll actually show you the little portal and show you the RICE scoring. Let me just get that working there.
So this is the little portal. It's been designed to work like a little app or a website, opens in PowerPoint. So you can click on stuff.
So it's just all clickable. So you can go through the different themes, or you can use the little arrows. You can go back.
You can go home, which was the first page.
You can pick on the different area, look at their list, look at their projection chart if you wanted to.
Or you can even look at the impact table with all of them on there.
But what I'll do is I'll show you a couple of examples.
So each of the areas, they've been themed and everything.
So I'll just pick on this one, which was a fast track pathway.
So as you can see, this is the sort of format that we used to score all the different initiatives. So we had a description, the aims.
We did have an impact projection tool, but that's for another showcase.
And then you've got the different scoring, the reach, impact, confidence, effort, etc. So in particular, this idea was a great idea on paper, came out with really good sort of promising scores, and it looked like, oh yeah, this could really make a difference.
And then when we did the reach and looked at how many people we actually had in thenservice to push this forwards, it had legs, but it didn't get taken forward simply because they didn't have the people and the staff behind it to push it forwards and really make it elevate and have a true impact.
So whilst it had a very high prospect of doing well, the amount of effort involved in actually getting there, we couldn't represent it to get it up there, we didn't have enough people out.
As we know, we didn't have the resource for this.
So this was a good idea, but it didn't quite have enough impact and enough resource to push the effort up to make it realize what it needed to do. So I'll go on to another one.
We've got communication and outreach.
So this one was an early awareness pilot and was previous work that was already being done but was extended to this.
And again, in the workshop, sounded like a great idea.
Get to the people before they need a referral.
Sounds like it'd have great impact.
But the problem with outreach is you never really know if it's actually having an impact on the immediate referrals coming in.
So whilst it was incredibly promising and will have an impact, it's more a longer-term thing because the thing that pulled the RICE score right down on this is, you can see it right there, the effort.
The amount of effort involved to do that outreach was just the thing that was pulling it down.
And our goal here was to come up with ideas that are going to have high impact on that waiting list sooner rather than later.
So while this is a great thing to have in the back pocket, it's not something that's going to help the immediate future.
So I'll show you another one here. So we've got reporting and automations.
On here, there's quite a few sort of digital enablers, and it was the same problem with all of them. They're all very helpful, but they all had the same issue. So I'll just pick on the AI triage one.
So the problem here was fantastic tool, would do a lot to help us, but the underlying issue was that they weren't seeing enough patients.
So you could have the quickest triage process in the world, but they weren't seeing enough patients. So when people were saying, "Oh, yeah, AI will help us with the triage," then when you actually put it into practice in the model, it wasn't actually taking anything forwards and pushing anything through the service any quicker. So Again, sounded like a good idea, but when you scored it, didn't score very high. I'll just move on to the last one here.
So these two got taken forward, so let's pick on this one because it's the biggest scoring one. So this one, quite simple.
Basically build a skill mix team to do more assessments.
So it was quite simply going to be, we're going to get more people in, we're going to borrow some people from different parts of the service and have a go at this.
And we knew it would have a big impact, and we were highly confident because we knew we could borrow the workforce from our own teams to do it, so scored incredibly highly.
And I'll just go to the impact table. So all of the different ones that we haven't looked at, they all go onto, well, the top ones go onto this impact table to give you an idea of that league scoring table that you could do. So impact projection tool was helpful as well.
But we have the RICE score there, as you can see, the RICE scores all going across the top there. And the ones that weren't taken forward but are in the backlog are in the gray there. So different ideas that you could take forward.
So let me just come out of the portal a second.
What was really handy about this is that you could then do this with the things that you just had in the RICE tool there.
And you have the things that are more waiting list recovery on one side of a polarity, and the sustainable ones on the other.
And you can quickly go, "Oh, those are the ones that are going to make the difference, the ones that are increasing capacity and adding resources." So those were the ideas that were in the tool there that the ones that we took forward.
So they're actually on the league table, and that's what helped us decide amongst all these ideas, which were the ones that were going to work.
So the RICE takeaway from all of this, I know I'm running out of time now. So it's very scalable, it's very accessible as a framework, but what I thought was quite useful about it, the most useful thing about it, was that when you're in a wicked mess, your instincts are to go for simplicity and make things easy to digest and really simple. But actually what was quite good about this, because it has that little bitb more detail, it actually helps you more delicately pick away at everything.
So if you just kept working on your ideas individual, and then when you put them all together in that league table or on that chart, you quickly start seeing a much bigger picture of what's going to have an impact.
So it was actually very good for what you would think you would need a simple idea.
It's actually something like this gives you that detail that helps you tackle it.
And it is very collaborative, so when we're doing all this, we were talking to the services and workshopping through all these RICE scores.
But the great thing about it is that you can continuously improve as you get more information and test things and pilot things, etc.
And it helps bridge that gap between what projection is to impact and benefit realization. So when we've got an idea, it can help us slide towards that actual reality of impact. Awesome.